Kramer (2003) describes the process of leaders who quickly rise to the top but then fall hard as the genius-to-folly syndrome – a swift and steady rise by a brilliant, hard-driving, politically adept individual, followed by surprising stints of miscalculation or recklessness (p. 60). Leaders often fail when this syndrome is present, aside from other factors such as incompetence and simply being unethical. Kramer stated, "I've found that there is something about the pursuit of power that often changes people in profound ways" (p. 60). There have been several key politicians, famous religious leaders, and well-known CEOs who have familiarized themselves with the rise and fall from the power pedestal of society. These leaders have been known to get distracted and often abandon the practices that helped them rise to the top. Usually, the qualities that help people achieve great things tend also to cause them to stumble (Sonnenfeld, 1997).
When sharing my insights on dilemmas that happen in society, I am reminded of the Enron scandal. This scandal resulted in the bankruptcy of the U.S. energy, commodities, and services company Enron Corporation and the dissolution of Arthur Andersen LLP, which had been one of the largest auditing and accounting companies in the world. Enron's collapse, which held more than $60 billion in assets, involved one of the biggest bankruptcy filings in the history of the United States. Enron's management aggressively steered its employees and consultants towards a misleading form of accounting that greatly inflated company profits. I remember this scandal well because my sister was an executive at the time of the demise and cashed in tons of stock options, which is how she paid in full for a 400k home in Texas. One guy that immediately stands out the most is Andrew Fastow. Andrew quickly rose through the ranks to become Enron's chief financial officer. Fastow oversaw the financing of the company through investments in increasingly complex instruments. Once Fastow moved up through the ranks, his demeanor began to change. Before he knew it, he was faced with an investigation by the SEC because he started to use fraudulent methods for personal gain while also treating people with contempt. Fastow's journey to success ultimately led to his downfall once he achieved a sense of power and had a taste of success. Often, the qualities that help people achieve great things tend also to cause them to stumble (Sonnenfeld, 1997). Fastow's downfall is somewhat representative of the same concept that Kramer (2003) mentioned in the article. Not everyone can handle a certain level of power ethically.
In my work life, I ethically tend to fall more into the deontological ethical framework than the consequentialist and therefore place a high value in following the rules. A situation I experienced at work was reporting an employee for stealing. The dilemma existed because I knew the employee was doing something that was against the moral and ethical standards of the organization, and it became my responsibility to report it. Here is an example: My co-worker was financially strapped and took money that was overpaid by a vendor. I knew no one would see the money was missing because the vendor was a last-minute walk-up. My co-worker needed the stolen money to survive because her husband had been without work for months. I was faced with "What should I do? If I turned them in, they would get fired and make their situation worse. If I didn't turn them in, I would become a party to their crimes. Although I didn't turn the co-worker in, I informed her what she was doing was unethical and she should report the overage. Days later, the vendor called and requested a receipt. The co-worker who failed to report the extra money was terminated. Luckily, I had covered myself because I made a note that there was extra money paid; however, we did not issue a receipt. My work dilemma was caused by not wanting someone to lose their job because I reported them, but at the same time, I needed to cover myself.
Lastly, in my experiences, I have learned that many people go throughout their lives with the desire to succeed. While not everyone may reach their desired level of success, some do rise to power. In some cases, if they can't get the rewards they seek through accepted channels, they may be desperate to do something unethical. Case in point, my friend and I both own an online boutique. I do it as a side business, whereas my friend does it for a living. We recently had the same popular product; however, I had more supply in stock. Believe it or not, my friend went behind my back to under sale the product to my customers via social media. When the client realized that my friend was not me, they called and informed my assistant. For months I have wanted to confront my friend; however, I don't want to end a friendship over money. My dilemma is that if I tell her how I know what she did, it will put my client in a precarious position and possibly cause me to lose their business in the future.
I've concluded that many ethical dilemmas result from finding out information that we're not supposed to know. Which ultimately causes many people to be an ethical quandary.
Kramer, R. M. (2003). The harder they fall. Harvard Business Review, 81(10), 58-66.
Sonnenfeld, J. (1997). How Leaders Fail. Leader To Leader, 1997(3), 34-38.